Retrospective: Identity (2003)

[Kam-Hung Soh]

Identity (2003)
A film review by Kam-Hung Soh
Copyright 2009 Kam-Hung Soh

On a stormy night, on the eve of a convicted killer's execution, the 
killer's defence team tries to persuade a judge that the killer is 
insane and should be committed to an asylum instead of being executed. 
The case for the defence rests on the judge examining the killer, so he 
is being transported from prison to the court house.  At the same time, 
ten travellers find that the highway is flooded, so they shelter from 
the rain in a motel. Among the travellers are Ed (John Cusack), an ex- 
cop driving a limousine, Paris (Amanda Peet), a call-girl and Rhodes 
(Ray Liotta), a police officer transporting a prisoner named Robert 
(Jake Busey). While they wait for the storm to abate, they find 
themselves being picked off, one by one, by a savage killer.

The start of the film is intriguing, with each person having a secret 
and a reason to distrust the others. However, after the first murder, 
things start to go downhill as the film veers between a slasher flick 
and an episode from 'The Twlight Zone'. Director James Mangold, who goes 
on to better things, doesn't handle the material well, relying too 
heavily on clichéd tricks to scare or horrify the audience. Even so, it 
could have been a passable popcorn flick ...

... Except that writer Michael Cooney adds one twist which invalidates 
the entire set up. We expect thrillers to use plot twists to keep you 
interested and a good twist (some so good that no one else could use it) 
would delightfully rearrange your perception of earlier scenes. In this 
film, the twist just made me feel cheated and after that point, I simply 
didn't care about what happens.

1 out of 5 stars.

http://vibogafi.blogspot.com/2009/09/review-identity-2003.html

-- 
Kam-Hung Soh
http://vibogafi.blogspot.com